Rare earth stocks index and REMX ETF alternative to build, weight and backtest against REMX
The largest rare earth ETF is about a quarter rare earths, with lithium, tungsten and molybdenum in the rest. Pick the producers and developers you actually want, set the weights, and see how the basket would have done next to REMX, REXC and the S&P 500. Then buy it at your own broker.
Pick 2 to 10 holdings. Stocks, ETFs and crypto mix in one index.
The backtest did not run just now. Tap Backtest it to try again.
Educational only · Never places a trade
In short
A rare earth stocks index is a basket of rare earth miners, separators and magnet makers that you weight yourself instead of taking a fund's rule. It matters because the rare earth ETFs own different things. Summing every holding in the latest SEC filings, companies whose main business is rare earths made up 87.5% of Sprott's REXC but only 23.5% of VanEck's REMX, the largest fund, 12.7% of Global X's EART and 10.5% of Sprott's SETM. Building your own means choosing that mix, backtesting it, and buying the shares with no yearly expense ratio.
Summed from each fund's SEC N-PORT filing
How much of each rare earth ETF is actually rare earths?
Every holding sorted by what the company mainly digs or makes. Rare-earth-first is a company whose main business or main project is rare earth mining, separation, metals or magnets. Partial is a producer that makes rare earths next to other minerals. Lithium is lithium miners and chemical makers. The rest is copper, uranium, tungsten, silver and everything else.
Sprott REXC
87.5% rare earth
Almost all rare earths, and no Chinese company by design
VanEck REMX
23.5% rare earth
The largest fund is a third lithium and 18.0% tungsten and molybdenum
Global X EART
12.7% rare earth
Copper miners are 36.3% and platinum group metals 11.9%
Sprott SETM
10.5% rare earth
Copper, uranium, lithium and silver come first
Start with REMX, because it is the rare earth fund most people find first and the only one with billions in it. It tracks the MVIS Global Rare Earth/Strategic Metals Index, and "strategic metals" is the part that carries the weight. Albemarle, PLS, SQM, Ganfeng, Liontown and six other lithium names add up to 35.7% of the fund. Xiamen Tungsten, Jinduicheng Molybdenum, Almonty and Jiaxin add another 18.0%. Only four holdings are rare-earth-first: China Northern Rare Earth, Lynas, MP Materials and Shenghe. If you bought REMX because of magnet supply and export controls, three quarters of the money went elsewhere.
REXC is the opposite answer. Sprott built it from rare earth companies outside China, and on June 30, 2026 Lynas (19.96%) and MP Materials (19.09%) were 39.0% of it, with Neo Performance Materials, USA Rare Earth, Critical Metals, Lindian and Arafura behind them. Its ten largest holdings were 75.2% of the fund, and much of the tail is Australian and Canadian developers without a producing mine. It launched on April 14, 2026, so there is no long record to judge it on, and at $55.9 million it is small enough that a closure is a real risk.
One classification call moves the numbers, so here it is. Iluka, Energy Fuels, NioCorp and Astron produce or plan to produce rare earths alongside mineral sands, uranium or niobium, so they sit in the partial band rather than the rare-earth-first count. Moving them in lifts REXC to 97.7% and REMX to 26.8% and changes no ranking.
From each fund's SEC filing and issuer page
Which rare earth ETF holds what, and what does each one cost?
| Fund | Expense ratio | Holdings | Assets | Largest positions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VanEck Rare Earth and Strategic Metals (REMX) | 0.53% | 30 | $2.69 billion (June 30) | Xiamen Tungsten 7.02%, Albemarle 6.99%, China Northern Rare Earth 6.82%, PLS 6.60%, Lynas 6.56% |
| Global X Rare Earth and Critical Materials (EART) | 0.59% | 50 | $38.8 million (July 31) | Anglo American 5.39%, Grupo Mexico 5.03%, Freeport-McMoRan 5.00%, Southern Copper 4.90% |
| Sprott Rare Earths Ex-China (REXC) | 0.65% | 41 | $55.9 million (June 30) | Lynas 19.96%, MP Materials 19.09%, Neo Performance 5.51%, USA Rare Earth 4.86% |
| Sprott Critical Materials (SETM) | 0.65% | 158 | $575 million (June 30) | Copper 26.5%, uranium 23.7%, lithium 19.0%, silver 11.3% of the fund |
The expense ratio is charged on the whole fund, so the lithium and copper you did not ask for still cost you the fee. Dividing the fee by the rare-earth-first share gives the yearly cost of each $100 of rare earth exposure: $0.74 for REXC, $2.26 for REMX, $4.65 for EART and $6.19 for SETM. That is our arithmetic, not a figure any issuer publishes, and the full ranking with the overlap between the four funds is in best rare earth ETF ranked by fee. Because REMX is a third lithium, compare it with the funds on our lithium ETF alternative page before you hold both.
// The universe, five groups
Which rare earth stocks can a US investor actually buy?
The rare earth industry is mostly listed outside the US. Lynas trades in Sydney, the two largest Chinese producers in Shanghai, and most developers on the ASX or the TSX Venture. What sits on a US exchange is short: MP Materials, which mines and separates at Mountain Pass in California and is building magnet capacity, USA Rare Earth, which is building a magnet plant in Texas, and Critical Metals, which owns the Tanbreez project in Greenland. A handful of US companies run a rare earth business inside something larger, and several foreign producers have over-the-counter lines that some brokers allow.
1
US exchange listings, rare earths first
2
US listings with a rare earth business inside
3
Foreign producers with US over-the-counter lines
4
Shanghai producers (most US brokers do not offer them)
5
A fund as one line to cover the long tail (optional)
The builder covers Nasdaq, NYSE and NYSE American listings plus US-listed ETFs, so groups 1, 2 and 5 go straight into an index. The over-the-counter and Shanghai lines in groups 3 and 4 are not in its catalog. For that exposure, hold REXC or REMX as one line, or load your own price series on the Team plan.
The first decision is producers against developers. MP Materials and Lynas sell product today and report revenue every quarter. USA Rare Earth, Critical Metals, Arafura and most of the REXC tail are spending money to build a mine or a plant, and their share prices move on financing news, permits and government contracts. A basket that gives the two producers half the weight behaves very differently from one that spreads evenly across twelve developers, so set that split on purpose instead of inheriting it from a fund.
Weighting is the next choice. MP Materials alone can be larger than the rest of the US list combined, so a market cap index across US listings is mostly one company. An equal weight index with a 15% or 20% cap on any single name keeps the developers visible without letting one of them sink the basket. If you want Lynas and the Shanghai producers without the over-the-counter lines, add REXC or REMX to the index as a single line.
From a view on magnets to a basket you can buy
How to build your own rare earth stocks index in four steps
1
Decide what counts
Rare earths only, or lithium and tungsten too? China in or out? Those two choices are most of the gap between REXC and REMX.
2
Fill the groups
Search the catalog of US-listed stocks, add the producers and developers you want, and set equal, size or your own weights with a cap.
3
Backtest against the funds
Run it against the S&P 500, and build a one-line index of REMX to put the fund on the same chart.
4
Track it, then buy it
Follow the index daily against its benchmark, export the weights, and place the basket at your own broker when you are ready.
Rare earth stocks move in bursts on policy news, which makes a backtest more useful than a fund factsheet. Read the maximum drawdown before the return: a basket of developers can lose more than half its value between two rallies, and that is the number that decides whether you hold on. Backtests are hypothetical and past returns do not predict future ones, and a backtest can only go back as far as your youngest stock, so a basket with USA Rare Earth or Critical Metals in it has a short history. If you cap the largest names, test a quarterly reset with the custom index rebalancing tool.
Three ways to own rare earth stocks, compared honestly
Build your own rare earth index vs a rare earth ETF vs a basket broker
| Rare earth ETF | Fidelity Basket Portfolios | Indexes, then your broker | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides what counts as rare earths | The fund's index | You | You, and you can test it first |
| Yearly cost | 0.53% to 0.65% of the balance | $4.99 a month flat | From $24 a month for the software, billed yearly, plus your broker's cost |
| Australian and Chinese producers | Yes, Lynas in all four, China in REMX | US listings only | US listings, plus any fund you add as one line |
| Test the design before buying | No, you buy the fund as built | No | Yes, back to your youngest stock |
| Per-stock tax losses | No | Yes, done by you | Yes, at your broker |
| Where it falls short | You take the fund's answer on lithium, tungsten and China | No way to test a design before buying | You place and rebalance the trades yourself |
The ETF wins when you want one ticker, Lynas and the Chinese producers you cannot buy in New York, and no upkeep. If that is the choice and the thesis is magnets, REXC is the closer match and REMX the more liquid one. Building your own pays off on cost once the balance is large enough that a flat $288 a year for the software beats the fund fee, about $54,000 against REMX and $44,000 against REXC, and whenever the mix you want is one no fund offers, such as the two producers at 50% and the US developers at 50%, with no lithium. Rare earth developers swing hard, so check the 30 day window with the wash sale calculator before you buy back a stock you sold for a loss.
What Indexes does and does not do: it is index construction, backtesting and tracking software. It does not hold money, place trades or give investment advice. You design and test the rare earth stocks index here and hold it wherever you already invest. The same method is on the build your own ETF page, and the copper mining stocks index applies it to the metal that fills EART and SETM.
Rare earth stock questions
What people ask before they buy rare earth stocks
What are the best rare earth stocks to buy?
The rare earth stocks that every rare earth ETF holds are MP Materials and Lynas Rare Earths, the two largest producers outside China. After them come USA Rare Earth, Neo Performance Materials, Iluka, Arafura and a long list of developers without a producing mine. Which mix is best depends on how much early-stage risk you accept, and you can backtest each mix on Indexes before buying.
What does the REMX ETF hold?
On June 30, 2026, REMX held 30 stocks led by Xiamen Tungsten at 7.02%, Albemarle 6.99%, China Northern Rare Earth 6.82%, PLS 6.60%, Lynas 6.56% and MP Materials 5.99%. Lithium miners were 35.7% of the fund and tungsten and molybdenum producers 18.0%. Companies whose main business is rare earths were 23.5%, and 35.3% of the fund was Chinese or Hong Kong listed.
Which US rare earth stocks trade on a US exchange?
MP Materials (MP) on the NYSE, USA Rare Earth (USAR) and Critical Metals (CRML) on Nasdaq are the main rare-earth-first names. Energy Fuels (UUUU), NioCorp (NB), Ramaco Resources (METC) and Idaho Strategic Resources (IDR) have rare earth projects inside a larger business. Lynas, Iluka and Neo Performance trade in the US only over the counter.
Is it cheaper to buy rare earth stocks than a rare earth ETF?
Past a certain balance, yes. A rare earth ETF charges 0.53% to 0.65% of your balance every year, while a flat $288 a year for the software beats a 0.53% fund fee above about $54,000 and a 0.65% fee above about $44,000. Owning the shares also lets you sell one loser for a tax loss and keep the rest, which a fund does not allow.
Is there a rare earth ETF without China?
Yes. Sprott Rare Earths Ex-China (REXC) holds no Chinese company by design and was 87.5% rare-earth-first on its June 30, 2026 filing. It is young, launched April 14, 2026, and concentrated: Lynas and MP Materials were 39.0% of the fund. REMX, the largest rare earth ETF, was 35.3% Chinese and Hong Kong listed.
How do I build my own rare earth stocks index?
Choose which companies count as rare earths, decide how much goes to producers versus developers, and set the weights, with a cap on any one stock. Then backtest the basket against REMX and the S&P 500 and track it daily. Indexes does the design, backtest and tracking, and you place the trades at your own broker.
Sources
Holdings and net assets from each fund's latest Form N-PORT on the SEC's EDGAR database, with report dates of June 30, 2026 for REMX, REXC and SETM and July 31, 2026 for EART, counting equity positions only. Expense ratios from the issuers, for example Sprott's REXC page, so confirm them before you buy. The groups are our own classification of each holding by its main business. Counted as partial: Iluka, Energy Fuels, NioCorp and Astron. Holdings change every quarter and the small developers move a lot between filings, so re-check before you buy. Indexes is not affiliated with any fund issuer, company or broker named here. We make index construction and backtesting software: we do not manage money, place trades or give investment advice, and backtested results are hypothetical.
Build the rare earth index you actually meant to buy
Choose the producers, the developers and the weights, backtest the basket against REMX and the S&P 500, and track it every day. Then buy it wherever you invest.